Just the facts. No fluff. RSS · About
NEW YORK Tuesday, November 3, 2026

New York

Yankees Considering Alternatives to Giancarlo Stanton as DH

Yankees may move away from Giancarlo Stanton as their designated hitter due to declining performance and defensive concerns.

New York Editorial News Desk October 27, 2026 1 min read

The Brief

  • Stanton's role as full-time DH is uncertain due to age and performance.
  • Ben Rice and Aaron Judge could fill the DH spot next season.
  • Defensive issues in the infield and outfield may limit Stanton's playing time.

The New York Yankees are evaluating their options for the designated hitter position, with Giancarlo Stanton's future in doubt. The team is considering alternatives due to his declining performance and defensive limitations.

Stanton is healthy, but there is no guarantee he will be the Yankees' full-time DH next season. Brian Cashman indicated this possibility last week, noting the team has other players who could take on the role.

Ben Rice has emerged as a potential DH, having shifted to that position after the acquisition of Luis García Jr. Aaron Judge, who played in only 66 games this season, could also benefit from more DH opportunities, though he is expected to remain in right field.

Stanton's defensive struggles prevent him from playing outfield regularly, unless in an emergency. The Yankees have two of the three outfield spots locked in for next season.

The Yankees face challenges in balancing offensive needs with defensive concerns. Moving Stanton to DH would leave the infield with defensive flaws, as Rice would play first base and García would take an infield spot.

Stanton's recent performance, including a postseason pinch-hit appearance without success, has raised questions about his value. The Yankees could opt to fully move on from Stanton and add a new everyday position player in his spot, though that plan has its own risks and concerns.

More in New York